A social site for poets in Sydney.
Is this poetry or invective? Not sure this is the appropriate forum either way.
Justin and Angel
My immediate response to this contribution is that it is invective. It demonstrates that not all contributors to ‘Sydney Poetry’ hold themselves to a sufficiently high standard before rushing into print. At the very least I suggest a re-examination of content, structure and presentation.
Beyond this, I am concerned to see work of this nature appear on the site. I believe it will have an alienating effect on other contributors in the same way that political diatribe and sectarian polemic will. For instance, I would not want to see the work of my friends or indeed my own work in proximity to this one.
Angel: I write this with good will. Please accept it as such. It is not my intention to inhibit the right of the writer to write in any style the writer deems appropriate however, may I suggest that you remember the idiomatic ‘horses for courses’ which means a racehorse performs best on a racecourse to which it is specifically suited. This concept, I believe, also applies to poetry.
Kindest Regards
Dermott Ryder
man, is that spoken word? I see where you're coming from - you're appropriating the voice of a white oppressor...from my reading this is not invective but hard passionate street politics - a pedagogy of the oppressed, but correct if I'm wrong Angel
I always think that it's not the invective, cussin' and swearin' that's the interesting thing, or even offensive, but the words around it, if there is anything offered in the poem apart from cussin' and swearin' that is. Do the victim and the perpetrator play out something interesting here, or is it all one-sided? I like to see the context for the feeling, the catalyst, the STORY. Then there's a compelling drama happening.Without those things in a poem, the language is just language, an exercise, a rant, a release of pain, which is so necessary when we hurt, but on its own not poetry.
Add a Comment
© 2024 Created by Adrian Wiggins. Powered by
You need to be a member of Sydney Poetry to add comments!
Join Sydney Poetry